Showing posts with label language. Show all posts
Showing posts with label language. Show all posts

Friday, January 31, 2014

On Depending Upon Others

One of the most frustrating things, for me, is feeling like I can't do things independently. This is why coming to India always drives me a little crazy. In a country where my accent gives me away immediately as a "foreigner," where I look like I should fit in but I definitely don't, where my lack of fluency in the local language morphs me from an articulate young woman to a stuttering, shy child, I am constantly frustrated. I want to be able to shop, visit the tailor, go buy a snack, or go visit my grandfather independently, but I can't, because it's dangerous for a young woman to be alone in this country, especially a woman who barely knows the local languages. 
Yet I hate having to constantly depend upon my relatives for help with everything from shopping to tailoring to traveling and more. I hate that I depended upon my great-aunt to get me great deals on clothes, yet she didn't tell me when I was paying too much for saris yesterday. I hate that my aunt and uncle and cousins in Chennai act like I'm inconveniencing them terribly when I ask for someone to travel with me to Tanjore to visit my aged grandfather, who was too ill to travel to Chennai himself. I hate that I rarely have privacy in this country. I hate that when you depend upon others for a while and come to feel that they're not only mentors but friends, they can change their behavior towards you in a flash, leaving you blindsided and wondering what you did that was so wrong. 
When I came to the airport last week to check in for my flight, I was surprised to see a family friend around my age in the same line. I didn't realize she was going to India on the same day as I was and I was even more surprised when I realized it looked like she was in line alone. Then I saw her mother in line next to her. When I said hi to her after a while, I mentioned that at first I thought she was going by herself, and she said, "Oh my God, do you think I'd go to India alone?" Well, I reminded her, I was doing just that. Because the truth is, I want to be able to do things by myself, especially things that scare me. Things like going to India. Because at least right now, at the end of the day, the only person who's always with me is, well, me. Better learn how to depend on myself as much as possible.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Diglossia

Disclaimer: I totally am not a linguist and don't really know anything about diglossia (or the Tamil language) on a scholarly level. I'm just venting a little here.

I wish I could write an exciting entry about all of the cool things I've been doing here in Chennai, but I've honestly not done that much cool stuff. More than anything, I'm sort of wrapping myself into the fabric of my extended family's shared life here. I eat lunch with my grandma, tiffin with Akhil, and dinner with the rest of the family. I'm reading quite ravenously (books by Chetan Bhagat, author of
Five Point Someone, upon which 3 Idiots was based, for now; I'll write an entry about his novels once I finish the last one I have by him), surfing the internet, and learning a sloka (prayer) in Tamil from my grandma. Which brings me, actually to the title of this entry: diglossia.

Diglossia is defined as "a situation where a given language community uses two languages or dialects," "the use of two varieties of a language by members of a society for distinct functions or by distinct groups or classes of people," and "the existence of two official languages in a society." And it's one of the characteristics of Tamil, my mother tongue (a phrase I believe only South Asian people seem to use...). What diglossia does to my world is mess it up. While Indian Americans whose mother tongue is Hindi can [with some effort] understand Hindi song lyrics, and Hindi poetry, can read a Hindi newspaper or watch a Hindi newscast and understand what he or she is reading or hearing, I can't do the same with Tamil.

Of course, I'm simplifying this a little: you'd have to be pretty proficient at Hindi to really understand a newscast or newspaper or poetry in the language, and I can definitely pick up words here and there in Tamil film songs if I try hard enough. But really: because I've never studied Tamil, only learned it through speaking to my family, I'm largely unaware of the true forms of most of the words I speak in this language. For example: if I were to say "it's raining" in Tamil, I would say "mazhai peyyarthu." But if I were to write it (or if the same phrase were to appear in a song, say), it would actually be "mazhai peygirathu." [And don't even get me started on transliterating Tamil; something as lovely as "moonlight caught in a bowl" looks a little ridiculous when you have to spell it out as "vennillaa velicham kinnaththil vizhinthu"] In short, the spoken form of my native language is kind of like AIM talk: abbreviations and shortenings galore. This would all be fine and dandy, if only I had been aware of this some time before I was around twenty years old. But I wasn't. So I went through a fair chunk of my life bemoaning the fact that I just didn't get Tamil. I could understand Hindi film song lyrics, for crying out loud, but lyrics in my own language, the first one I ever spoke, went over my head. What's wrong with that picture, right?

Thankfully, finding out about diglossia served to relieve me of my slight inferiority complex/identity crisis. It also, though, makes me feel a little cheated. Wouldn't life be so much easier if I were a native Hindi speaker and didn't have to work so darn hard to decipher my own language? I feel a bit like I'm being cheated of some sort of linguistic birthright. I mean, Tamil has a proud literary tradition: It not only predates Sanskrit, but has outlived it as a spoken language. But I find myself on the outside of much of its beauty, simply because I never formally learned it. I was hoping to learn Tamil in earnest (from my grandmother, a retired schoolteacher; she taught music in school, but she definitely knows Tamil well enough to teach it) during my time here, but I kind of lost interest somehow or other. Maybe I should do what I can in my last seven days. When all you're doing is reading novels and playing on your iPod Touch and bumming around, I'm sure you could squeeze lots of learning into the time that would have been whiled away otherwise.

To that end, I'm going to go chill with my grandma now.